Title: Dumbledore Dead or Alive?
Finnigan Tatupu - July 12, 2006 03:32 PM (GMT)
Tiegan_Syeira - July 12, 2006 04:12 PM (GMT)
As much as I want him to be alive, he is dead. Thats just the way it is.
Coldstone_Harshing - July 12, 2006 04:17 PM (GMT)
Moved, this should be in the HP disscussion.
Squall Leonheart - July 12, 2006 06:35 PM (GMT)
Finnigan Tatupu - July 12, 2006 07:37 PM (GMT)
Alive
I really like this article and this is what I agree with.
http://www.mugglenet.com/editorials/editor...t-erezr01.shtml Squall Leonheart - July 12, 2006 08:19 PM (GMT)
not nearly enough evidence to make me support it. i prefer this.
Slughorn Theory Finnigan Tatupu - July 12, 2006 09:00 PM (GMT)
They both have about the same amount of proof... I just gave one article... anyone else have other theories?>
Lyra Braque - July 14, 2006 12:05 AM (GMT)
Dumbledore's dead, snape made an unbreakable promise, whether it was in his power or not dumbledore is D.E.A.D.
Finnigan Tatupu - July 14, 2006 12:52 AM (GMT)
No, he just promised to help Draco. We aren't entirely sure what Draco's promise to Voldemort was. We think it was to kill dumbledore but we aren't sure.
Coldstone_Harshing - July 14, 2006 06:46 AM (GMT)
No Fin, the slughorn switch has a tower of evidence from where JK got her ideas from and also little hints in the book.
Squall Leonheart - July 14, 2006 03:47 PM (GMT)
i agree with Adam, i think that the proof in the slughorn switch theory towers over the potion theory.
Finnigan Tatupu - July 14, 2006 08:04 PM (GMT)
It would make sencse to me that JK pu something seemingly unimportant as a major clue in the plot.
Squall Leonheart - July 14, 2006 08:24 PM (GMT)
like the hands for instance? and the speech?
Alexia Traut - July 17, 2006 10:00 PM (GMT)
I dunno if hes dead....theres not a lot of evidence for him being both dead nad alive